Is the arm stroke in swimming a ‘pull’?

Children take what adults say literally.  It is one of the reasons I often discourage coaches from being sarcastic in a training session when they attempt to be funny sarcastically.  Swimmers don’t get it.  They think that coaches and adults mean what they say.  Children are influenced by their teachers and the words they use are important.  So why do we call the underwater part of our arm stroke a ‘pull‘ when it isn’t?teaching with songs

To pull means something different than what we do to the water if we are swimming correctly.  If you imagine a tug-o-war (a former Olympic event) then you will imagine ‘pulling’.  A person on the tug-o-war team holds onto the rope and pulls towards themselves.  The elbows are tight into the body and biceps are straining.  We don’t pull in swimming; we press and push.  You would not make the Olympic Tug-o-war team if you tried to press the rope towards you.

So why do we use the term pull when we mean the opposite? Coaches know  Newton’s Third Law allows us to move through the water by pressing and pushing the water backwards so that we go forwards.  But pressing and pushing is completely different to pulling.  I think the word ‘pull’ in swimming circles has simply become universal practice.  However I think we are planting a seed in children’s minds that  may be causing some of the problems that are common mistakes.

Forearms

I believe that using words which mean something different than what we intend opens up a can of worms.   If we want our swimmers to drop their elbows and ‘pull’ then we should shout, “PULL HARD”, and it would give you the opposite result that we truly want.  The catch phase of each stroke includes manipulating the elbow and shoulders to allow a good hold with both the hands and forearms.  The stroke then ‘presses’ until we reach the shoulders and then we push (or in-sweep in breaststroke).

Breaststroke 1

In all the swimming strokes I believe we need to consider carefully the words we use.  The term ‘kick’ is keeping our leg action isolated to the legs when a full body action is required.  The term ‘pull’ implies we should use a tug-o-war action and this is wrong.

So the pull is not a pull, and if we are not careful we will reap what we sow.

Advertisements

About Coach Gary

I competed in the 1988 Olympics in Seoul representing Canada and coached in the 2000 and 2004 Olympics for Great Britain. I have a degree in History and a minor degree in Psychology from University of Calgary. I have travelled extensively and have been very lucky to see so much of the world while representing Canada and Great Britain at swimming competitions. I am very proud of the fact that I coached a swimmer to become number one in the world in the fastest swimming race in 2002. I pride myself in my ability to find new and interesting ways to teach swimming. I am an accomplished artist specialising in sculpture, I have another blog called 'swimmingart' where I publish some of my swimming drawings. I have three young children; all boys. I have recently taken up painting and yoga....but not at the same time. You can see my new paintings at: https://www.artgallery.co.uk/artist/gary_Vandermeulen
This entry was posted in General Knowledge on swimming and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Is the arm stroke in swimming a ‘pull’?

  1. Pingback: Water is heavy | swimcoachingblog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s